Agent Skills
› brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills
› the-burlington-magazine
the-burlington-magazine
GitHub用于评估稿件是否符合《伯灵顿杂志》的发表标准，聚焦于鉴定、归属、出处及实物艺术史研究。提供选题定位、证据门槛分析及拒稿启发式规则，辅助作者判断适配性并优化论证框架。
触发场景
作者投稿关于作品鉴定、出处或博物馆展览的稿件，需进行适配性检查
需要强化基于实物与档案证据的论点以符合期刊高标准
在《伯灵顿杂志》与通用或理论导向的艺术史期刊间进行选择
需要了解该期刊对实证研究的严格标准及快速拒稿常见原因
安装
npx skills add brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills --skill the-burlington-magazine -g -y
SKILL.md
Frontmatter
{
"name": "the-burlington-magazine",
"description": "Use when targeting The Burlington Magazine or deciding whether a connoisseurship, attribution, or object-based art-history manuscript fits this venue. Encodes the journal's fit as the leading venue for connoisseurship, attribution, provenance, and museum\/exhibition scholarship, the evidentiary bar for object-based claims, primary-source command, house style, image-rights expectations, official-submission re-check, and desk-reject heuristics."
}
The Burlington Magazine (the-burlington-magazine)
Journal positioning
The Burlington Magazine is the pre-eminent venue for connoisseurship and object-based art history: attribution, dating, provenance, technical and conservation findings, and the scholarship of collections, exhibitions, and the art market. Its defining expectation is a precise, well-documented contribution that advances knowledge of a specific work, group, or body of evidence — a new attribution, a rediscovery, a documentary or technical finding, or a corrective to the record — argued from direct examination of the object and the primary sources. Broad theoretical essays with no object at their center, or speculative claims unsupported by close evidence, are a poor fit here. This skill is a fit / venue-selection / re-framing aid. It does not replace the journal's current submission guidelines. Before submitting, re-check the live Burlington Magazine author instructions.
When to trigger
- The author names The Burlington Magazine for an attribution, provenance, technical, or museum/exhibition manuscript and wants a fit/framing check.
- An object-based finding must be tightened around its documentary and visual evidence and its place in the record.
- The author is choosing between The Burlington Magazine and a generalist or theory-driven art-history journal.
- The author needs the journal's connoisseurship/evidence bar and desk-reject heuristics.
Scope & topic fit
- Attribution, re-attribution, and dating of works, argued from direct examination, style, and documentary evidence.
- Provenance research, rediscoveries, and corrections to the historical record of specific works or groups.
- Technical art history and conservation findings — materials, technique, underdrawing, and scientific examination — bearing on attribution or understanding.
- Documentary discoveries: archival finds, inventories, contracts, and correspondence that reshape what is known about a work, artist, or collection.
- Scholarship of collections, museums, exhibitions, and the history of taste, collecting, and the art market.
- Catalogue and corpus-level contributions that advance the documentation of an artist or school.
Method & evidence bar
- The contribution is a precise, well-grounded object-based claim — an attribution, finding, or correction — stated clearly and supported by direct evidence.
- Close visual and material examination of the work(s) is central; stylistic and technical observation is described exactly and tied to the conclusion.
- Command of primary sources and documents — archival records, inventories, provenance trails, technical reports — is thorough and read critically.
- Where relevant, technical and scientific evidence (imaging, materials analysis) is reported accurately and its limits acknowledged.
- Engagement with the existing literature and catalogues situates the claim against prior attributions and the documentary record.
- Conclusions are proportionate to the evidence; alternatives are weighed, and uncertainty is stated rather than overclaimed.
Structure & house style
- Focused article or shorter note built around a specific object, finding, or documentary discovery; re-check current article types and length expectations on the live guide.
- Citation follows the journal's current style with full notes; provenance and archival references follow the journal's form.
- Anonymization for review per current policy where applicable (self-citations and acknowledgements).
- Image rights are central and the journal is illustration-led: secure high-quality reproduction permissions for every work discussed, including comparative images and technical photographs, and budget for fees before acceptance.
- Figures must meet the journal's specifications (high resolution, format, captions, credit lines, dimensions and medium) with permissions and an illustration list.
- Foreign-language documents are quoted and translated per policy; transcriptions of archival sources follow the journal's conventions.
Official-submission checklist
- Before giving submission-ready advice, read
../../resources/source-basis.mdand../../resources/official-source-map.md; start from the journal's publisher anchors, then cite the current Burlington Magazine page you checked. - Search the live site for "The Burlington Magazine submission guidelines" and follow the current version.
- Re-check article types (article vs. shorter note), length expectations, and any abstract requirement.
- Confirm the citation/style format and any anonymization for review.
- Re-check image-reproduction permissions, high-resolution figure specifications, the illustration list, and any reproduction-cost policy.
- Re-check competing-interest, funding (if applicable), and AI-use disclosure, plus any translation/transcription policy for archival sources.
- If the live official instructions conflict with this skill, the official instructions win.
Pre-submission self-check
- The object-based claim (attribution, finding, or correction) is stated precisely and is the center of the piece.
- Close visual/technical examination and documentary evidence directly support the conclusion.
- Primary sources, provenance, and prior catalogues are addressed and the claim's uncertainty is stated.
- Anonymization for review (where required) follows current policy.
- High-resolution reproduction permissions are secured and figures meet specifications.
- Archival transcriptions and non-English documents are quoted and translated per policy.
Common desk-reject triggers
- A broad theoretical essay with no specific object or documentary evidence at its center.
- An attribution or provenance claim that overreaches the evidence or ignores prior catalogues.
- Vague stylistic assertion not anchored in close examination or technical/documentary support.
- Speculative reconstruction unsupported by archival or material evidence.
- Missing high-resolution image permissions, or figures below the journal's specification.
- Wrong venue: a conceptual or theory-driven argument better served by a generalist or theory journal.
Re-routing decision
- Broad, all-periods generalist art-history article →
the-art-bulletin. - Theoretically and methodologically reflective art history →
art-history. - Contemporary art, criticism, theory, or the avant-garde →
october. - Interdisciplinary critical theory across the humanities →
critical-inquiry. - Aesthetics / philosophy of art is the core contribution →
the-journal-of-aesthetics-and-art-criticism.
Output format
[Fit] High / Medium / Low (one-line reason)
[Target] The Burlington Magazine
[Field/period/region] <closest field, period, region, or collection>
[Argument] <the object-based claim in one line — attribution, finding, or correction>
[Objects/images] <the specific work(s) examined and the visual/technical evidence>
[Sources/documentation] <does the documentary + examination evidence clear the connoisseurship bar?>
[Image permissions] <are high-resolution reproduction rights and figure specs in hand?>
[Top risk] <the single most likely reason for rejection>
[Official items to re-check] <article type / citation style / anonymization / image permissions / transcription>
[Re-route suggestion] <if not a fit, a better-matched venue>
版本历史
- 1839142 当前 2026-07-05 12:58
