ndss-workflow
GitHub用于规划NDSS论文提交日历，对比夏秋两季周期，从AoE截止日倒推至会议。涵盖早期拒稿、反驳、通知及相机就绪等关键节点，并指导在大四会议年中的策略选择与责任披露时间管理。
Trigger Scenarios
Install
npx skills add brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills --skill ndss-workflow -g -y
SKILL.md
Frontmatter
{
"name": "ndss-workflow",
"description": "Use when planning an NDSS submission calendar — choosing between the summer and fall cycles, backward-planning from the AoE deadline through early-reject, rebuttal, notification, camera-ready, and the Seoul symposium, and placing NDSS honestly inside the security big-four retargeting year."
}
NDSS Workflow
One symposium, two entrances. NDSS 2027 accepts papers through a summer cycle and a fall cycle, each a complete two-round review pipeline, both feeding the same week in Seoul (22-26 March 2027). Plan against the cycle you can actually win, not the one that arrives first.
The 2027 skeleton (verified 2026-07-08; always recheck the live CFP)
| Milestone | Summer cycle | Fall cycle |
|---|---|---|
| Paper deadline (AoE / UTC-12) | May 6, 2026 — passed | August 19, 2026 |
| Early-reject notification + Round-1 reviews | June 12, 2026 | September 25, 2026 |
| Rebuttal + interactive discussion | June 24-28, 2026 | October 8-10, 2026 |
| Final notification | July 22, 2026 | November 4, 2026 |
| Camera-ready (both cycles) | January 6, 2027 | January 6, 2027 |
| Symposium (Seoul) | March 22-26, 2027 | March 22-26, 2027 |
As of 2026-07-08 the summer cycle is between rebuttal and notification; the fall deadline is roughly six weeks out. Registration for Seoul opens in October 2026 (Internet Society announcement) — for many teams the 2027 edition also means visas and long-haul travel budgets that San Diego never required. Start that paperwork at acceptance, not at camera-ready.
Backward plan from a fall submission
Aug 19 paper deadline (AoE) ── freeze everything
Aug 12 full-draft freeze ── format, anonymity, ethics-section passes only
Aug 05 internal red-team read ── someone plays the Round-1 reviewer
Jul 29 evaluation freeze ── last new experiment; start writing results
Jul 15 disclosure clock check ── vendor notifications sent early enough that
"we disclosed" is true at submission time
Jul 08 (today) go/no-go ── fit test done, adversary model written,
headline experiment already running
The item teams misplace is the disclosure clock: responsible disclosure has latency measured in weeks, and the CFP expects reporting (or a concrete plan) for high-impact vulnerabilities. A finding made on August 10 forces an uncomfortable choice; a finding made in July does not.
Choosing the cycle
- Enter the earliest cycle whose backward plan closes with the evaluation done, not projected. A thin submission is worse than a late one here, because a rejection blocks major-overlap resubmission in the other 2027 cycle.
- The rebuttal window is short and fixed (Oct 8-10 for fall). Check coauthor availability during those exact days before committing.
- A Major Revision outcome converts the calendar: you get reviewer-specified revision tasks and a resubmission window (dates 待核实 — confirm on notification). Budget the post-notification month as working time, not celebration time.
The big-four year, seen from the NDSS seat
The four flagship deadlines interleave, and NDSS's late-summer fall deadline sits where papers rejected from the S&P and CCS spring/summer cycles and the USENIX Security year naturally land. Two honest rules for riding this calendar:
- Retargeting without revision is re-rejection. Reviewer pools overlap heavily across the big four; a resubmission that ignores its previous reviews often meets the same people. Fold in the fixes, and re-frame for NDSS's networked-adversary lens rather than doing a logo swap.
- NDSS is a venue, not a fallback tier. Its acceptance bar is a peer of the other three; a paper that was thin at S&P is thin here too. What legitimately changes is fit — protocol, web, DNS, and distributed-infrastructure work often reads better to an NDSS PC than it did wherever it bounced.
Running the year
- Track each paper as a state machine:
drafting → submitted → round-2 | early-reject → rebuttal → accept | minor-rev | major-rev | reject, with an owner and a next-action per state. The review-process skill details what each state means. - On early reject (with Round-1 reviews in hand): route to the next venue on the
routing table in
ndss-topic-selection, after folding in the reviews. The same-edition door is closed; the 2028 door is not. - On accept / minor revision: fork immediately into camera-ready (January 6 is far but
the artifact-evaluation opt-in is near — see
ndss-artifact-evaluation) and logistics (registration, visas, who presents). - Keep the per-author six-submission cap visible on the group's board each cycle; it binds collaborations with many shared authors sooner than people expect.
Output format
[Cycle chosen] summer / fall / next edition — one-line justification
[Backward plan] table of dated freezes ending at the AoE deadline
[Disclosure clock] green / yellow / red + earliest safe submission date
[Rebuttal window] coauthors confirmed available? yes/no
[Post-decision branches] accept / minor / major / reject → owner + next action each
[Logistics] Seoul registration, visa lead time, presenter
Version History
- 9f86f09 Current 2026-07-19 17:06
